Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter

There is an impostor among us, an identity thief! It’s a peanut! Did you know that a peanut is neither a pea not a nut? I’ts actually a legume. So let’s help these well-loved sneaky peanuts blend in by making peanut butter!  Homemade peanut butter is simple, fresh, fragrant, and delicious. It’s also so simple that you may never buy jars of peanut butter again.

Check out my Video Demonstration for Peanut Butter here, where I used inspiration from Amazon’s “Sneaky Pete”!  VIDEO DEMONSTRATION!


To make this peanut butter you only need a handful of ingredients. First, make sure that you have Spanish Peanuts. Spanish peanuts are usually found in the baking aisle at your local grocery store. They are smaller in appearance than the peanuts you may usually buy to snack on. They’re also less oily, so make the ideal key ingredient for homemade peanut butter.

These Spanish peanuts still have a little bit of the skin on top that you will rub off after they have been roasted. But the first step is to toss the raw Spanish peanuts in some peanut oil and some sea salt. When salting, go by your preference. If you want extra salt or no salt at all in your peanut butter , that’s fine too. Then after you have everything salted and oiled put the peanuts onto a baking sheet that’s lined with some parchment paper.

Roasted Peanuts

These are what your peanuts will look like after they’ve been roasted for about thirty minutes in the oven. They’re browned, they’re shiny from natural oil as well as the peanut oil, and they’re giving off a really nutty, fresh aroma.

Peanut Prep!

Before you blend, all of the little skins need to come off. As soon as these cool, go through with this towel and rub off each piece of peanut to get all of that skin out.

rub skins off peanuts

The easiest way, if the skins don’t just pop off when touched, is to go ahead and take your peanut that has the skin on it, put it into a towel, and just rub it. The skin peels right off and you’ve got your peanut butter ready peanut! Then do that with all of them. You can put a few down on the towel, rub them down, and throw them in a bowl to make it go a bit faster.

Butter, Baby!

And now let’s make some peanut butter!

Use a food processor. Put all of your cleaned peanuts into it. Then add a bit of honey. The honey will add that honey roasted flavor.

honey roasted peanut butter

Then just blend it all up! This does take a few minutes. It will get all finely crushed then slowly turn into peanut butter. Note that when it turns into a ball, you are about to get that creamy butter you have worked so hard for!

homemade creamy peanut butter

Then, look what happens!

fresh peanut butter

In my house, we love creamy peanut butter! So I went the extra step and really blended this down so that it got ground into the creamiest peanut butter. You can always stop earlier at the consistency you desire!

Amazon's Sneaky Pete Inspired Recipe

Look at that! It looks so good! And it smells even better! So, as you can see, the smell of the freshly roasted peanut butter is gathering a crowd! So I better get this peanut butter in a bowl. I went with creamy peanut butter because that’s what our family loves. And look at this, you have freshly roasted peanut butter. When I made this video, Tilly got the smell and came running for a bite! It is just that good!

Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter

Amazon’s ‘Sneaky Pete’ VIDEO DEMONSTRATION!


  • 1 bag of raw Spanish peanuts
  • 2 Tablespoons Peanut Oil
  • 1 teaspoon sea salt (salt to taste)
  • 1 teaspoon honey


  • Preheat oven to 325 degrees
  • Toss raw peanuts with oil and salt
  • Put peanuts in a single layer on baking sheet.
  • Roast for 20-30 minutes, until peanuts are browned and giving off nutty aroma.
  • Allow to cool.
  • Once cool, get skins off of peanuts.
  • Put peanuts into your food processor.
  • Drizzle in honey.
  • Blend until your desired consistency.


  • Note that the blending takes a few minutes, so just let it keep blending until it reaches a ball, then it will become creamy right after that. If you want crunchy then make sure to watch for the consistency you want!
  • You can swap out honey for sugar or leave it out completely.
  • Salt to your preference!
  • Use this peanut butter to make a variation of :

Essentials For Making Peanut Butter!

Check out these Ritzy Recipes!

Butterscotch Birds Nests

Flourless Peanut Butter Cookies with Dark Chocolate Drizzle

Red Wine Popcorn